ROCK MOMENT – Eagles ‘I Can’t Tell You Why’
The Eagles’ 1980 ballad ‘I Can’t Tell You Why‘ holds a special place in the band’s history, both musically and personally. Featured on their final studio album before their first breakup, The Long Run, the song marked a new direction for the group while also showcasing a fresh voice. Unlike their signature country-rock hits, this track leaned into a smooth, R&B-influenced sound, often described as the Eagles’ most soulful recording.
The song was written primarily by bassist Timothy B. Schmit, who had only recently joined the band in 1977, replacing Randy Meisner. Schmit brought the initial idea to guitarist Glenn Frey and drummer Don Henley, who helped polish and complete the composition. According to Schmit, the lyrics reflected struggles in relationships but were not autobiographical—rather, they captured universal themes of love, uncertainty, and communication breakdowns.
When recording the track, Schmit was given the opportunity to sing lead—a rare move for a new member in such a high-profile band. His gentle, falsetto-driven performance gave the song its emotional core and instantly distinguished it from other Eagles singles. Released in February 1980, it climbed to No. 8 on the Billboard Hot 100, becoming Schmit’s first hit as a vocalist with the band.
Live, ‘I Can’t Tell You Why’ became a showcase moment for Schmit. Even after the Eagles reunited in the 1990s, the song remained a staple, often drawing some of the night’s loudest applause. Beyond the Eagles’ own performances, the track has enjoyed a wide legacy. Artists like Brownstone in the 1990s and jazz guitarist Howard Hewett offered soulful reinterpretations, while countless smooth jazz musicians have covered it, proving its versatility. Its enduring influence even crossed into television—appearing on shows like Miami Vice—cementing its reputation as one of the Eagles’ most timeless ballads.
